“The Pianist (Part One)” – a short story by J. C. Michaels

November 4th, 2024

.

.

“The Pianist (Part One)” was a finalist in our recently concluded 66th Short Fiction Contest, and is published with the consent of the author.

.

.

___

.

.

Munich University of Music and Theater/© Raimond Spekking/via Wikimedia Commons

.

 

The Pianist (Part One)

by J.C. Michaels

.

 

…..The thin-legged, short-statured, bald-headed professor paces tersely around the room, which is half-filled by a pair of ebony, six-foot, side-by-side Steinway grand pianos. He stops and stares at me sitting on the piano bench hunched submissively downward. I turn part way around and glance upward as he pats his rotund belly like Renaissance nobility after a holiday feast but with a scowl suggesting the digestion has not gone well.

…..“There’s a professional and instructive way,” Harmel says, then strides toward the window behind his desk. He pauses to look at a distant tree and then begins bobbing his head front to back with increasing amplitude as he mumbles. “The direct way is best…. Clean, precise … no chance for misinterpretation.” Then he turns, stands behind his desk, and leans on his knuckles.

…..“What the hell were you doing?” he bellows.

…..I glance at his puffing cheeks and taught lips…. I have been on campus three days, known this professor of piano for less than a half-an-hour, and played for less than ten minutes. How can the sounds of a piano could so dramatically alter another’s emotional state?

…..“What was all that pedal doing in Bach? … And the rubato in the opening? … And those ill-defined mordents? … Your playing offends the dead.”

…..He scrunches up his nose and winces as though a foul odor is permeating the air.

…..“Your playing is a horribly confused mixed metaphor of sixteenth-century Baroque, nineteenth-century schmaltz, and twentieth-century jazz. I would rather be subjected to nails on a chalkboard or Muzak in an elevator. Are you some kind of anarchist! Where did you learn to play like that?”

…..“I—”

…..“Stop.” Harmel says, stretching out his palm toward my face. “I really don’t want to know. Words are not going to help you. All that matters is the music—and if reform is possible.”

…..Beads of frustrating sweat erupt from his shiny forehead, gently drip down his small nose and toward his thin upper lip. His portly nature causes his arms to rotate outward slightly from the sides of his body, creating an almost cartoonish outline against the bright sunlit window.

…..“I hope you’re up for this,” Harmel snaps as he sits behind his desk, dropping into his chair with exhaustion, resting his elbows on the table, pressing his palms against his cheeks. “You realize,” he says, “I am also your academic counselor. I’m thinking a degree in piano performance is not a good choice. You can still switch your enrollment. Go to the College of Liberal Arts. Major in history, or psychology, or swimming—anything but music.”

…..“I like piano,” I say, then look away.

…..Harmel points a stiffened finger at me. “I don’t care what you like. I’m trying to decide if teaching you is what I like,” he says, thumping sternum. “I’m not the kind of professor inspired by the challenge of transforming mediocre and unprepared students. That’s to be done by others—before entering the College of Music.”

…..I hear his anger, but I don’t feel it. I just feel out of place as though I have accidentally opened the wrong door, perhaps one that should have remained locked.

…..“I can make a phone call,” he says eagerly. “You can transfer today.”

…..I don’t react to his taunts. I won’t transfer. I will drop out. I will tell my mother I never wanted to play anyway. I was just trying to please a man she detested—that will get her support. I will find a menial job, rent a cheap room, buy a grand piano, and sleep underneath.

…..“Don’t just sit there,” Harmel blurts out. “Speak up. Do you want to transfer?”

…..I think about the events that have resulted in my enrollment. At the age of five, my father told me music opened the mind and heart to new ways of seeing the world. I didn’t know what he meant, only that it pleased him. I practiced almost every day for the next five years. But that was not good enough to keep him home. He left the family and disappeared. I continued practicing for eight more years, hoping that when he returned, he would happy, admire my diligence, maybe even be proud…. He never returned, but I could neither stop practicing nor hoping. I needed to play as well as possible, so good and so impressively that if he came back, he would be compelled to stay.

…..“Well?” Harmel asks, standing up, moving toward me, staring down at my shoulders. “Has your tongue been eviscerated? Are you collapsing at the first sign of criticism? Just tell me, were you taught this way, or did you learn on your own?”

…..“I’ve had lessons, but mostly on my own.”

…..“A homeschooled pianist. Good god.” Harmel flops down onto a dark leather couch directly behind me.

…..I twist around but keep my feet on the pedals.

…..“By the way,” Harmel says, “were those extra notes in your left hand a mistake or some jazz riff you decided to toss in.”

…..“Uh—”

…..“Don’t answer. I don’t want to hear any teenage blabbering from a pimply faced freshman. If you’re going to take that kind of freedom—write your own damn music! I am here to teach you to perform great works by great masters—not to compose. Do you understand? There is a way to play Bach, and a way to play Beethoven, and a way to play Mozart. You are not here to be a composer or even represent a composer. You are here to serve the composer. When you humbly master their work and understand their expectations and the style of their era, then and only then—perhaps—you can take a few liberties with a grace note. Until then, you honor their work exactly as written and keep your pubescent desires to yourself. Are we clear? … “Just one question I would like answered. Who auditioned you?”

…..“Nelert,” I mumble.

…..“Of course, a doctoral student. You auditioned at the last minute when the rest of us were on summer vacation. The administration is always trying to fill empty slots with paying bodies. Congratulations on a lucky draw…. One more question, if I may. Did you request me or was this your unlucky draw?”

…..I roll my shoulders in an ambiguous manner.

…..“I’m a curious old man,” he says, lifting his brows.

…..I turn back toward the piano and stare at the white spaces between the black keys…. I carefully read Harmel’s biography. He had studied with the great pianist van Heijnoort, who studied with the composer and pianist Béla Bartók, who studied with Istvan Tolman, who studied with the first solo pianist Franz Liszt, who studied with Carl Czerny, who studied with the towering figure of Ludwig van Beethoven. Real or imagined, like family lineage, musical lineage is also a connection to the past. Perhaps, like father to son, destiny can be passed on.

…..“Yes, I did request you,” I say quietly, “but I—”

…..“I don’t want to hear anymore. You’ve dug a hole big enough to swallow a ten-foot Bösendorfer—and you’re liable to fall in and get slammed by the piano lid.” Harmel laughs at his own words, then walks over to shelves filled with music scores. He pulls out the Bach Preludes and Fugues and tosses the music in front of me. “How fast can you learn a new piece?” he asks.

…..Harmel seems like a general preparing for battle, invigorated at the prospect of mortal combat with a student. Take down the young upstart with a quick head lock and an arm twist, see how much you can make him squirm. I also see a man of uncompromising belief in how the world should be. Strangely, inexplicably, I feel an allure to his confidence and certainty.

…..“I can learn fairly quickly,” I say.

…..“Good. You have some talent,” he says, opening the music. “These pieces are rites of passage.”

…..I look at the music then reach out my right hand and begin to play part of a treble line.

…..“Stop!” Harmel bellows. “What the hell are you doing? I don’t want to hear you practice. That’s what the practice rooms are for. Can you learn this piece in a week—memorized?”

…..I flip through several pages noting the complex arrangement of four independent voices. “I don’t know, probably not.”

…..“Well, I didn’t think so.” Harmel snatches the book from the piano and tosses it onto the couch. “We have a lot of work to do—a lot of work.” He clears his throat, returns to his chair, and props his feet on his desk. Suddenly, he appears peaceful, like a lion sated after devouring a kill of fresh meat.

…..“Do you have anything else you’d like to play?” he asks.

…..“You want to hear something else?”

…..“Can you play anything else?”

…..“I could improvise.”

…..“What!” Harmel retracts his feet and leans against the edge of the desk as though bracing himself for a storm. “Oh god no…. I hope you’re joking. I mean classical repertoire, not trifles emerging from your jazz tainted, adolescent mind.”

…..“Then I have nothing else to play.”

…..“Good…. I’m relieved.”

…..Harmel leans back in his chair as though exhausted from a full day on the frontlines. He takes a few deep breaths and then attempts to comport himself in a tempered and professional manner. “Close the keyboard cover,” he says. “I don’t want to hear any more.” He rubs his forehead and asks in a calm tone, “Does anyone in your family play piano?”

…..I turn my head sharply. My eyes flash. My answer is quick and stern. “Does that matter?”

…..“Maybe not,” he says, a bit taken aback by my indignant tone. “I’m just curious…. What kind of piano did you play when you were growing up?”

…..“An Erard,” I answer flatly.

…..Harmel bolts forward and slaps his palms on his desk. “An Erard,” he repeats skeptically, “Are you … sure?”

…..“I’m sure. The instrument was passed down through my mother’s family. She’s Venetian.”

…..“I can’t believe it. I would have guessed a sawed-off spinet.” He laughs as he slaps his hands playfully on his thighs. “Erard invented the double-escapement mechanism, the foundation of all modern pianos. Did you know that?”

…..I nod.

…..“Did you know Beethoven wrote compositions just for this instrument?”

…..I nod.

…..“And that Erard gave Liszt pianos to play?”

…..I nod.

…..“And that Venice has an extraordinary artistic lineage, a place very few can still call a home?”

…..I nod.

…..“You are given a gift from history, and yet know nothing of how to play it.”

…..Harmel smiles like a villainous mentor.

…..“If I already knew such things,” I say, in an edgy manner, “what would be the purpose of teaching me?”

…..Harmel scowls and nods in a self-congratulatory way, affirming his mastery and knowledge.

…..“You obviously can play,” he says. “You just can’t play well. You need to realize this is a music conservatory. We conserve the past. Although small, we are one of the most prestigious piano departments in the country. This school is for students fully committed to the art of performing serious music. Students who want to be professional accompanists, world-class educators, concert pianists. Do you understand?”

…..I look away. I feel exposed like someone claiming to be a visual artist whose only experience is painting by numbers…. Maybe I did not fully understand the expectations of a conservatory. Maybe I did just get in on a fluke. Maybe I am here for the wrong reasons. But I am here. And now that I am, I want to know if I can become the kind of pianist a person will remember.

…..I look at Harmel and offer a singular nod. “Yes, I understand. I’m ready to begin.”

.

.

___

.

.

The Pianist (Part One)  is an excerpt from an unpublished novel, Dream and Deception.  If you’d like to read another excerpt from this novel, click here.

.

 J. C. Michaels is an award winning, internationally published novelist from the U.S. currently living and working as a literary writer in Taiwan.

 

.

.

.

___

.

.

Click here to help support the continuing publication of Jerry Jazz Musician, and to keep it ad and commercial-free (thank you!)

.

Click here to read “Not From Around Here,” Jeff Dingler’s winning story in the 66th Jerry Jazz Musician Short Fiction Contest

Click here to read more short fiction published on Jerry Jazz Musician

Click here to read The Sunday Poem

Click here for information about how to submit your poetry or short fiction

Click here for details about the upcoming 67th Jerry Jazz Musician Short Fiction Contest

Click here to subscribe to the Jerry Jazz Musician quarterly newsletter (it’s free)

.

.

.

___

.

.

 

Jerry Jazz Musician…human produced (and AI-free) since 1999

.

.

.

Share this:

Comment on this article:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Site Archive

Your Support is Appreciated

Jerry Jazz Musician has been commercial-free since its inception in 1999. Your generous donation helps it remain that way. Thanks very much for your kind consideration.

Click here to read about plans for the future of Jerry Jazz Musician.

In this Issue

Announcing the publication of Volume II of Kinds of Cool: An Interactive Collection of Jazz Poetry...The second edition of Kinds of Cool, an Interactive Collection of Jazz Poetry has just been published, and is now available for sale on Amazon.com. This edition is dedicated to publishing women poets from all over the world who share their personal passion for and relationship with jazz music, and the culture it interacts with. With a foreword by Allison Miller, one of the world’s most eminent jazz drummers, and photography and design by Rhonda R. Dorsett

Poetry

photo of Shelly Manne by William Gottlieb/Library of Congress
21 jazz poems on the 21st of May, 2026...An ongoing series designed to share the quality of jazz poetry continuously submitted to Jerry Jazz Musician. In this edition…An array of poetic styles communicate personal reverence for and experiences with jazz music, and its cherished musicians.

The Sunday Poem

Marek Lazarski, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The Sunday Poem: “Sonny Rollins” by Akua Lezli Hope

The Sunday Poem is published weekly, and strives to include the poet reading their work...

Akua Lezli Hope reads her poem at its conclusion.


Click here to read previous editions of The Sunday Poem

Performance

The performance poet Emmett Wheatfall
A Letter from the Editor…On “The Weary Blues: Celebrating Langston Hughes and the Harlem Renaissance”A brief recap and photos of the February 7, 2026 Jerry Jazz Musician-produced performance of “The Weary Blues: Celebrating Langston Hughes and the Harlem Renaissance”

Interview

photo of Billie Holiday by William Gottlieb/Library of Congress
Interview with Paul Alexander, author of Bitter Crop: The Heartache and Triumph of Billie Holiday’s Last Year...The author talks about the courage and resilience of the legendary Lady Day, and his outstanding book – an inspirational and revealing portrait of an iconic American, that, like his subject, exudes compassion and creative soul.

Feature

Book Excerpt from Crossing Bar Lines: The Politics and Practices of Black Musical Space, by James Gordon Williams...In this entire chapter from his book, the author explains how the trumpeter Ambrose Akinmusire expresses his political views and lived geography through his improvisational music, notably his critique of police brutality that has, as he states, “become a leitmotif throughout my albums.”

Poetry

Yves Moch, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons
“Remembering Sonny Rollins” – a collection of poetry...Over the years, many poems have been published on Jerry Jazz Musician that were written in reverence of the man we refer to simply as “Sonny.” In the wake of his death, many more have been written. The unsolicited poems making up this collection is an example.

Short Fiction

Photo by Johannes Schröter, via Pexels
Short Fiction Contest-winning story #71 – “Where the Music Wasn’t Allowed,” by Jane McCarthy....The award-winning story is about a young immigrant growing up in Southern California to the sound of music seeping into his family’s home from an upstairs neighbor’s piano, shaping the boy’s understanding of memory, family, belonging, and the improvisational ethics of music.

Interview

photo by Warren Fowler
Interview with John Gennari, author of The Jazz Barn: Music Inn, the Berkshires, and the Place of Jazz in American Life...The author discusses how in the 1950s the Berkshires – historic home to the likes of Hawthorne, Melville, Wharton, Rockwell, and Tanglewood – became a crucial space for the performance, study, and mainstreaming of jazz, and eventually an epicenter of the genre’s avant-garde.

Poetry

photo by Tsutumu Takasu/via Flicker/CC BY 2.0
“Cajun Glory” – a prose poem by Robert Alan Felt

Community

Ricky Esquivel/Pexels.com
Community Bookshelf #6...“Community Bookshelf” is a twice-yearly space where writers who have been published on Jerry Jazz Musician can share news about their recently authored books and/or recordings. This edition includes information about books published within the last six months or so (September, 2025 – March, 2026)

Poetry

Six poets write eight poems (in the midst of our times)...Poets within this community of writers are feeling this moment in time, and writing about it. This collection is another example.

Short Fiction

“You Don’t Know What Love Is”- a short story by L.F. Graubard...A recovering junkie jazzman in a Starbucks time slips through the key years that fed his addiction — 1967 R&B and jazz gigs, ’69 biker bars, ’71 methadone hustles, ’79 script scams — before landing in the Narco Farm, where music, Sonny Rollins, and Secretariat crack his heart open. A fractured, noir confession about love, dope, and improbable grace.

Poetry

Peter Buitelaar, CC BY 2.0 , via Wikimedia Commons
Two Poems for Miles Davis

Feature

photo by Laura Stanley via Pexels.com.
Trading Fours, with Douglas Cole, No. 28: “Little Samba”...Trading Fours with Douglas Cole is an occasional series of the writer’s poetic interpretations of jazz recordings and film. This edition is based largely on a documentary – They Shot the Piano Player – about Tenório Junior, a Latin jazz musician who only produced one album (1964) before he “disappeared” in 1976.

Short Fiction

“From Ingenue to Earth Mother” – a short story by Lisa Grunberger...The story – a short -listed entry in the recently concluded 72nd Jerry Jazz Musician Short Fiction, centers on a couple who “get” each other from the beginning, but who can’t seem to make a life together.

Poetry

art by Marsha Hammel
“Learning the Alphabet of the Blues” – a poem by Mary K O’Melveny...A poem from Kinds of Cool: An Interactive Collection of Jazz Poetry, Vol. II

Short Fiction

Alejandro Aznar/via Pexels.com
“Down at the Crossroads” – a short story by David Rudd...In this story – a finalist in the recently concluded 71st Jerry Jazz Musician Short Fiction Contest – a jazz composer hears a lone fiddler play a tune that enters his head and won’t leave it, like a virulent earworm, wrecking his playing, his friendships, and indeed, his life, until he finally finds a way to remove it.

Feature

photo via Wikimedia Commons
Memorable Quotes: Two, by Edward R. Murrow…

Feature

photo via Wikipedia
“Two Famous Johns” – a true jazz story by Bob Hecht...The writer remembers an evening in New York’s Half Note in 1964 when he witnessed a John Coltrane performance that was also attended by the pop singer Johnny Mathis

Poetry

Haiku: Musings – by Connie Johnson...Exploring segments of the world of jazz – in three suites of vivid haiku poetry…

Jazz History Quiz

photo of "Hot Lips" Page by William Gottlieb
Jazz History Quiz #187...This trumpeter began his career in California, where he organized a big band that had a residency in China in 1934, and, during a trip through Kansas City in 1936, was invited to join Count Basie’s orchestra, replacing “Hot Lips” Page (pictured). Who is he?

Feature

“Bohemian Spirit” – A Remembrance of 1970’s Venice Beach, by Daniel Miltz...The writer recalls 1970’s Venice Beach, where creatives chased a kind of freedom that didn’t fit inside four walls…

Feature

Boris Yaro, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
“The Bowie Summer” – a personal memory, and how art can fundamentally reshape identity, by G.D. Newton-Wade

Poetry

Poems on Charlie “Bird” Parker (inspired by a painting by Al Summ) – an ekphrastic poetry collection...A collection of 25 poems inspired by the painting of Charlie Parker by the artist Al Summ.

Feature

Albert Ayler’s Spiritual Unity – A Classic of Our Time, and for All Time – an essay by Peter Valente...On the essence of Albert Ayler’s now classic 1964 album…

A Letter from the Publisher

The gate at Buchenwald. Photo by Rhonda R Dorsett
War. Remembrance. Walls.
The High Price of Authoritarianism– by editor/publisher Joe Maita
...An essay inspired by my recent experiences witnessing the ceremonies commemorating the 80th anniversary of liberation of several World War II concentration camps in Germany.

Interview

Interview with Tad Richards, author of Listening to Prestige: Chronicling its Classic Jazz Recordings, 1949 – 1972...Richards discusses his book – a long overdue history of Prestige Records that draws readers into stories involving its visionary founder Bob Weinstock, the classic recording sessions he assembled, and the brilliant jazz musicians whose work on Prestige helped shape the direction of post-war music.

Contributing Writers

Click the image to view the writers, poets and artists whose work has been published on Jerry Jazz Musician, and find links to their work

Coming Soon

New poetry collections, Jazz History Quiz, and lots of short fiction; poetry; photography; interviews; playlists; and much more in the works...

Interview Archive

Ella Fitzgerald/IISG, CC BY-SA 2.0 , via Wikimedia Commons
Click to view the complete 25-year archive of Jerry Jazz Musician interviews, including those recently published with Judith Tick on Ella Fitzgerald (pictured),; Laura Flam and Emily Sieu Liebowitz on the Girl Groups of the 60's; Tad Richards on Small Group Swing; Stephanie Stein Crease on Chick Webb; Brent Hayes Edwards on Henry Threadgill; Richard Koloda on Albert Ayler; Glenn Mott on Stanley Crouch; Richard Carlin and Ken Bloom on Eubie Blake; Richard Brent Turner on jazz and Islam; Alyn Shipton on the art of jazz; Shawn Levy on the original queens of standup comedy; Travis Atria on the expatriate trumpeter Arthur Briggs; Kitt Shapiro on her life with her mother, Eartha Kitt; Will Friedwald on Nat King Cole; Wayne Enstice on the drummer Dottie Dodgion; the drummer Joe La Barbera on Bill Evans; Philip Clark on Dave Brubeck; Nicholas Buccola on James Baldwin and William F. Buckley; Ricky Riccardi on Louis Armstrong; Dan Morgenstern and Christian Sands on Erroll Garner; Maria Golia on Ornette Coleman.